Freedom from Emotional Eating, Food & Weight Obsession

My “Maggeroni’s” Last Gift

Maggie at her Favorite Dog Park

I was recently reminded of an emotional truth. I like to think of it as my dog Maggie’s final gift to me.

I lost Maggie recently. By “lost” I mean I ended her life.  I can honesty say it was the most difficult thing I have even deliberately done.

“Maggeroni” was amazing, nearly fifteen year’s old; way older than the oldest age shown on the dog years-to-human years conversion chart at her Vet’s office. According to that chart, big dogs don’t get to be Maggie’s age. So in recent years I made it a point to be grateful for every single day she was still with me. I kissed her more often and actually told her how grateful I was that she was my dog. She just loved me back and let me bury my face in that soft thick ring of fur around her neck.

I prayed that when her time came, she would just naturally slip away. But that was not to be.

I first met Maggie on New Year’s Eve day, 1997, in the “green room” of a morning TV talk show . She was nine weeks old and looked like a chubby white bear cub. I had been invited on the show to talk about emotional eating. She was there to be adopted. I commented on how cute she was and before I could blink, the “adopt-a-pet” lady had Maggie on my lap. And that was that. By nightfall, we were family.

She was scary smart; one of those dogs who knew most of her toys by name. People said they had never seen a dog with such an expressive face. We always knew what she was feeling. And she was fiercely protective of me.

She came to work with me every day when I ran my binge eating disorder treatment center. When I moved to my home office six years ago, she spent every day by my side, often right next to my desk chair.  She was a wonderful companion. After me, the dog park was what she adored most!  See that smile?

People said, “You’ll know when it’s time. Your dog will let you know.” But Maggie did not tell me anything of the sort. This past year her head and heart were still fine. But her hips and legs were failing her. We had delayed the inevitable through a year and a half of holistic care; acupuncture, supplements, and anti-inflammatory meds. But those treatments were no longer working. The quality of her life had diminished, significantly and consistently. She had lost twenty five pounds since the end of 2011, but she still seemed to love being here. Her final week she was not eating (except treats, of course, which were never turned down), and she was having a tough time getting outside. Both her regular and holistic vets said it was time. 

After much soul searching and many tears, reluctantly, I made a plan. I decided she would pass away in her own bed, in her favorite spot, in our home, after eating a whole bowl of her favorite treats.

But moments after she was euthanized, I felt this overwhelming sense of guilt; like I had somehow betrayed her. She did not go peacefully, as I was told she would.

A week later, I was still having trouble shaking the feelings. Determined not to turn to emotional eating to manage my emotional pain, I got some help. I knew I needed to talk this through.

My Vet had mentioned a Pet Hospice program in my city called Angel Paws. I went to the website and learned that coaching was offered to help people deal with the loss of a beloved pet. I scheduled a phone session.

After getting some background, the coach asked me to identify the actual thoughts that were driving my feelings of guilt and betrayal. My mind immediately went to a conversation I’d had with my next door neighbor the day before Maggie’s last day. When I told my neighbor of my plan and asked if she wanted to say goodbye to Maggie, she got very upset with me, challenged my decision, told me it was not Maggie’s time to go. She said she could not talk to me about this, went inside and slammed her door.

That conversation kept playing over and over again in my head.

Then the coach asked me to recall the thoughts I had had that lead me to decide it was time to help Maggie go. I easily recounted the consults I’d had with Maggie’s long term Vet and the holistic Vet who had been treating her with acupuncture. They had both seen Maggie within days of my decision. I also recalled the third opinion I’d gotten from the mobile Vet who came to our home on Maggie’s final day. As the hospice coach pointed out, in the days after Maggie’s death I had been choosing only to focus on the conversation with my opinionated neighbor, not on the conversations with the dog experts who actually knew Maggie’s health status and gave me educated, humane recommendations.

In my grief, I’d forgotten that I get to choose my thoughts.  I was too sad to remember what I already knew; that my thoughts drive my feelings.  I, and I alone, give my thoughts power. When I chose only to replay the conversation with the neighbor, I was driving my guilt. I was not thinking about or remembering the reasons that lead me to humanely and compassionately end Maggie’s suffering. I did it because I loved her with all my heart!  

My guilt lifted. I did not betray my Maggeroni. I loved her! I loved her enough to do what I needed to do, even though it was the most difficult thing I had ever done.

I still occasionally feel that guilt come back. When it does, I consciously choose to shift my thoughts. I remember how much I loved her and how I wanted her to be free.

Rest in peace my dear Maggeroni…thank you for being my best friend for fifteen years…I will love you forever…


“His ears were often the first thing to catch my tears.”                                                                ~Elizabeth Barrett Browning, referring to ‘Flush’ her Cocker Spaniel

“I guess you don’t really own a dog, you rent them, and you have to be thankful that you had a long lease.”  ~Joe Garagiola


Ellen Shuman is a Life Coach who specializes in empowering people who are working on emotional and binge eating recovery. She is the founder of A Weigh Out & Acoria Eating Disorder Treatment, President of the Binge Eating Disorder Association (BEDA), and Co-Chair of the Academy for Eating Disorders Special Interest Group on “Health at Every Size”,

Found this article useful? Please share it with your followers!


Free Guide + "Ellen's Weekly Empowerment Tips"

About Ellen Shuman

Ellen on the phone

I have worked in the Wellness Field for 30 years. I created an Emotional Eating & Binge Eating Disorder Recovery Program way before most people knew BED was an eating disorder, NOT a “willpower” issue. Personally, I suffered for years before finding answers and the help I needed and deserved! I became a Coach in 1997 to help others who were still suffering as I had. I love being a Coach!


Related Articles

Listening Without Judgment

I was having my hair highlighted recently. My colorist rents one of those tiny salon spaces with just two chairs. The colorist introduced me to


“Each man must look to himself to teach him the meaning of life. It is not something discovered; it is something molded.” ~Antoine De Saint-Exupery

Another Reason NOT to Diet!

______________________________ Ellen Shuman is a pioneer in the field of Binge Eating Disorder; a Life Coach who specializes in helping people overcome emotional eating, compulsive

Nutrition and Immunity

Although we are all susceptible to the occasional cold or flu, there are some ways to ensure that your immune system is functioning at its